O
Monterey County
← Community
Public SafetyCommunity discussion

Sheriff's Office Collaboration with ICE and Truth Act Report

Monterey County

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Supportive (10)Opposed (19)Concerned (38)

At a glance

Public comments
67
Last 30 days
0

Last discussed Jan 27, 2026.

Public comments (67)

ConcernedRobert DanielsJan 27, 2026

Demanded accountability and transparency following the fatal police shooting of Ronald Tinsley in Marina.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:08:33 →
ConcernedLavisha FranklinJan 27, 2026

Spoke as a mother of Black sons, demanding systemic police reform and accountability.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:11:03 →
ConcernedJulie AltmanJan 27, 2026

Urged an independent investigation into the death of Ronald Tinsley and adherence to truth and care.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:15:14 →
ConcernedHenry PerezJan 27, 2026

Demanded justice, transparency, and an independent investigation into the killing of Ronald Tinsley II.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:11:50 →
ConcernedLisa StewartJan 27, 2026

Expressed deep concern over officer conduct and the narrative surrounding Ronald Tinsley's death.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:24:03 →
SupportiveCatherine FeneauJan 27, 2026

Voiced support for community accountability regarding both immigration enforcement and local police shootings.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:21:42 →
OpposedRenee YoungJan 27, 2026

Called for the termination and criminal charging of officers involved in the shooting of Ronald Tinsley.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:25:01 →
ConcernedRosalind GreenJan 27, 2026

Demanded the unedited release of body camera footage and independent oversight of law enforcement.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:27:19 →
ConcernedAndrea ManzoJan 27, 2026

Called for accountability, independent investigation, and accurate public records regarding police shootings.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 6:25:17 →
ConcernedKyle AndersonJan 27, 2026

Questioned officer accountability, toxicology screens, and background disclosures following the fatal shooting.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:34:31 →
ConcernedJohn SilvaJan 27, 2026

Asked the board to use its influence to ensure accountability within the Marina Police Department.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:43:01 →
OpposedMiriam SmithJan 27, 2026

Demanded the firing of officers involved in the fatal traffic stop and independent oversight.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:43:52 →
ConcernedTamesha SmithJan 27, 2026

Stated that systemic racial bias in policing must be addressed with transparency and accountability.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:48:17 →
ConcernedVanessa HillJan 27, 2026

Demanded transparency and an independent investigation into the killing of Ronald Tinsley.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:50:07 →
ConcernedRosa GonzalezJan 27, 2026

Called for equitable actions, housing support, and justice for Ronald Tinsley II.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 1:56:37 →
ConcernedPastor SmithJan 27, 2026

Expressed grief and demanded justice and righteous policing in memory of Ronald Tinsley.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:02:47 →
ConcernedNinaJan 27, 2026

Spoke as an educator and teacher of the victim's daughter, urging accountability and care for youth.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:06:00 →
SupportivePaola BertoisJan 27, 2026

Supported bike path development and expressed solidarity with community members seeking justice.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:08:19 →
OpposedMarta Carolina GonzalezJan 27, 2026

Submitted a formal complaint regarding the handling of her mother's death by authorities.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 3:37:00 →
SupportiveElois HelmJan 27, 2026

Expressed support for law enforcement enforcement of laws and raised concerns about repeat criminal offenders.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 3:40:00 →
OpposedCarla LoboJan 27, 2026

Criticized the lack of leadership and accountability regarding the Tinsley shooting.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:16:36 →
ConcernedNellyJan 27, 2026

Demanded strict enforcement of the law regarding a traffic fatality case.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:17:19 →
OpposedRamesha SmithJan 27, 2026

Criticized the district attorney's office for avoiding accountability and defaming the deceased.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:19:23 →
SupportiveCaroline CarrollJan 27, 2026

Requested transparency, unedited footage, and community grief support following the Tinsley shooting.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:22:47 →
OpposedJanayJan 27, 2026

Criticized officer actions during the traffic stop and demanded criminal charges.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:24:59 →
ConcernedKiara HaydenJan 27, 2026

Demanded full release of footage, independent investigation, and correction of false gang affiliation claims.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:25:32 →
ConcernedCatherine CrockettJan 27, 2026

Expressed concern over discrepancies in police accounts and urged a transparent investigation.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:28:59 →
ConcernedDean JanetJan 27, 2026

Shared personal connection to the victim and condemned police unprofessionalism.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:08:40 →
ConcernedPastor LusterJan 27, 2026

Highlighted the lack of humanity and transparency from law enforcement during the tragedy.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:12:30 →
ConcernedBridget Allen MurrayJan 27, 2026

Emphasized supervisors' roles in enforcing police accountability and community safety.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:34:15 →
SupportiveAnita CrawleyJan 27, 2026

Called for a fair, independent investigation to foster community growth and healing.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:35:50 →
ConcernedSpencer StewartJan 27, 2026

Demanded answers, accountability, and transparency regarding the killing of Ronald Tinsley II.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:37:04 →
ConcernedMartha LobosJan 27, 2026

AdvOCATED for the unhoused community and called for thorough investigations into police department conduct.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 2:38:27 →
ConcernedTom O'KeefeJan 27, 2026

Expressed deep concern from the Public Defender's office regarding transparency on ICE access.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 3:57:34 →
SupportiveMauricio AriasJan 27, 2026

Spoke on behalf of Assemblymember Dawn Addis, emphasizing state support for immigrant legal aid and transparency.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 3:58:38 →
ConcernedMargaret Sedna BonettiJan 27, 2026

Expressed concern over ICE collaboration and requested public defender oversight for jail interviews.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 6:40:00 →
OpposedMelissa FinchJan 27, 2026

Criticized local cooperation with federal agencies given documented abuses and lack of due process.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:02:31 →
SupportiveCatherine ThomasJan 27, 2026

Voiced support for federal immigration enforcement and raised personal grievances regarding child welfare.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:04:55 →
ConcernedJuliet SpontumiJan 27, 2026

Urged the board to re-evaluate optional participation in the SCAP program and ICE collaboration.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:07:06 →
OpposedAdrianaJan 27, 2026

Urged the county to eliminate all collaboration with ICE to protect community trust.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:09:46 →
OpposedJoana TapiaJan 27, 2026

Stated that collaboration with ICE is optional and called for an end to entanglement with federal enforcement.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:14:19 →
OpposedAnna MendozaJan 27, 2026

Spoke as a human trafficking survivor and farmworker, urging protection and support for immigrant workers.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:17:14 →
OpposedColleen IngramJan 27, 2026

Urged the county to end participation in SCAP and cease data sharing with ICE.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:19:05 →
ConcernedMickey WelshJan 27, 2026

Called for civilian oversight of the sheriff's office and an end to voluntary ICE cooperation.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:21:24 →
ConcernedSharon MillerJan 27, 2026

Appealed for an ordinance establishing civilian oversight of the sheriff and cessation of ICE cooperation.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:23:35 →
ConcernedMibs McCarthyJan 27, 2026

Expressed disappointment in sheriff cooperation with ICE and advocated for civilian oversight.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:25:16 →
OpposedClarissa Reyes BecerraJan 27, 2026

Emphasized that ICE transfers are discretionary under California law and urged the county to halt them.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:27:11 →
ConcernedMarianne GowenJan 27, 2026

Expressed concern as an unincorporated county resident regarding the erosion of trust caused by ICE collaboration.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:24:57 →
OpposedJan SchreinerJan 27, 2026

Urged the sheriff's office to end participation in federal data-sharing programs like SCAP.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:31:31 →
OpposedJosh VonJan 27, 2026

Criticized federal enforcement tactics and urged the sheriff to protect residents from unconstitutional actions.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:35:40 →
SupportiveRosie SanchezJan 27, 2026

Urged the county not to cooperate with ICE, highlighting the contributions of migrant families.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:38:39 →
ConcernedAlma CervantesJan 27, 2026

Highlighted increased military-style policing in South County and requested the sheriff end ICE cooperation.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:40:27 →
ConcernedGeorge ViaJan 27, 2026

Expressed concern over the fear caused by sheriff collaboration with ICE in the community.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:42:02 →
SupportiveJoanna GallagherJan 27, 2026

Urged the sheriff's office to refuse cooperation with ICE to protect constitutional rights.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:44:25 →
ConcernedNicholas CurryJan 27, 2026

Suggested considering a recall petition if the elected sheriff's policies do not align with community values.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:55:52 →
ConcernedNoel FletcherJan 27, 2026

Criticized the lack of comprehensive answers from the sheriff's office regarding community questions.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:47:07 →
OpposedYajira LopezJan 27, 2026

Stated that voluntary cooperation with ICE harms immigrant communities and undermines public safety trust.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:47:07 →
ConcernedMartasa MogriJan 27, 2026

Called for proactive planning and transparency to protect residents from potential federal overreach.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:49:57 →
OpposedMagnoliaJan 27, 2026

Urged the county to end all ICE collaboration and demand full transparency from the sheriff.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:51:42 →
ConcernedDalton WinterJan 27, 2026

Warned against local law enforcement turning on peaceful community members during federal actions.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:52:57 →
ConcernedCarson FoxJan 27, 2026

Questioned the rationale of handing over individuals to an agency bypassing constitutional law.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:54:00 →
ConcernedAlicia Marie RaglandJan 27, 2026

Urged an end to ICE cooperation and mentioned recall options if public confidence continues to erode.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:55:07 →
OpposedMegan WildenJan 27, 2026

Encouraged the county to reject ICE cooperation and begin planning for community defense against federal raids.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:56:28 →
ConcernedBev KrepsJan 27, 2026

Requested legal observers for the sheriff's office and an immediate halt to ICE cooperation.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:58:13 →
SupportiveHelen CochemsJan 27, 2026

Called for immediate board action to establish a committee protecting the county from ICE, similar to Santa Cruz.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 4:59:19 →
OpposedJasmine TopitJan 27, 2026

Stated that collaboration is still collaboration and urged an end to ICE cooperation to protect families.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 5:00:34 →
OpposedDeja RobinsonJan 27, 2026

Called on the sheriff's department to end collaboration with ICE and prioritize community safety and compassion.

Board of Supervisors — January 27, 2026 · 5:02:24 →